हिंदी में पढ़ें, यहाँ क्लिक करें →
हिंदी

Topics › Polity & Governance

Money Bill and Budget

UPSC asked 12 questions on public finance between 2011 and 2026. Most test two things: exactly how far the Rajya Sabha can go with a Money Bill, and who does what in the Budget, where UPSC quietly puts the Prime Minister in the President's place.

12past questions
7of the last 16 years (2011 to 2026)
5trap types
12word swaps
Constitutional overview: Articles 109 to 117 and 265 to 267

Core aim: no tax without law and no spending without Parliament's approval, with the Lok Sabha holding the purse.

Art. 109
Special procedure for Money Bills: introduced only in the Lok Sabha; Rajya Sabha returns within 14 days with recommendations.
Art. 110
Definition of a Money Bill (only taxes, borrowing, the funds, appropriation, charged expenditure); the Speaker's decision is final.
Art. 112 to 116
Annual Financial Statement (112), estimates and demands (113), Appropriation Bill (114), supplementary grants (115), vote on account (116).
Art. 117
Finance Bills: category I needs the President's recommendation and starts in the Lok Sabha; category II is like an ordinary bill except it needs a recommendation to be considered.
Art. 265
No tax shall be levied or collected except by authority of law.
Art. 266 and 267
Consolidated Fund and Public Account (266); Contingency Fund (267).

What UPSC asked

2011
4
2012
1
2013
1
2014
0
2015
2
2016
0
2017
0
2018
1
2019
0
2020
0
2021
0
2022
0
2023
1
2024
2
2025
0
2026
0

Traps

Each trap below is one UPSC actually used. The question where it appeared is linked, so you can solve it right after reading.

Swap: who acts

Giving a financial role to the wrong person. The President causes the Budget to be laid and recommends every demand for grant; the Finance Minister lays it on the President's behalf, not the PM's; Parliament alone authorises withdrawal from the Consolidated Fund; the Department of Economic Affairs, not Revenue, prepares the Budget.

Rajya Sabha's limits

Overstating or understating the Rajya Sabha. It cannot reject or amend a Money Bill or vote on demands for grants, and must return the bill within 14 days. But it can discuss the Budget, and the Lok Sabha is free to ignore its recommendations.

Money Bill vs Finance Bill

Treating every Finance Bill like a Money Bill. A Money Bill (Art. 110) has only the listed matters; a Finance Bill of category I (Art. 117(1)) also has other matters and the Rajya Sabha can amend or reject it, and a joint sitting is possible (not "necessary") for it.

Which fund

Mixing up the three funds. Consolidated Fund (Art. 266(1)): all revenue and loans, withdrawal only by law. Public Account (266(2)): money held in trust, no vote needed. Contingency Fund (Art. 267): at the President's disposal for unforeseen spending, made good later.

Something that does not exist

A convincing institution that India does not have, such as a Parliamentary Budget Office, slipped into a list of real controls.

Word swaps

A swap is the one word UPSC changes to turn a true statement false. Learn the right word and you can spot the swap in seconds.

The right factUPSC swapped it toAsked in
FM lays the Budget on behalf of the PresidentOn behalf of the PM2024 Q4
Lok Sabha may reject Rajya Sabha recommendationsMust accept them2024 Q17
Finance Bill: joint sitting possibleJoint sitting necessary2023 Q6
Appropriation: from the Consolidated FundFrom the Contingency Fund2018 Q8
Budget prepared by Department of Economic AffairsDepartment of Revenue2015 Q7
Public Account: no parliamentary voteNeeds authorisation2015 Q7
Rajya Sabha can discuss the BudgetCannot discuss it2015 Q12
Money Bill: no joint sittingPresident calls a joint sitting2013 Q18
India has no Parliamentary Budget OfficePBO reviews programmes2012 Q12
Budget defeated: whole Council resignsOnly the FM resigns2011 Q5
All revenue: Consolidated FundPublic Account2011 Q7
Withdrawal authorised by ParliamentBy the President or FM2011 Q8

Solve the past questions

Try each question first. Tap an option to see the answer and the trap.

UPSC 2024 Q4
With reference to Union Budget, consider the following statements: 1. The Union Finance Minister on behalf of the Prime Minister lays the Annual Financial Statement before both the Houses of Parliament. 2. At the Union level, no demand for a grant can be made except on the recommendation of the President of India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (b). The trap: Article 112: the President causes the Annual Financial Statement to be laid; the Finance Minister does it on the President's behalf, not the PM's. Statement 2 is Article 113(3). Answer (b).
UPSC 2024 Q17
Which of the following statements are correct in respect of a Money Bill in the Parliament? 1. Article 109 mentions special procedure in respect of Money Bills. 2. A Money Bill shall not be introduced in the Council of States. 3. The Rajya Sabha can either approve the Bill or suggest changes but cannot reject it. 4. Amendments to a Money Bill suggested by the Rajya Sabha have to be accepted by the Lok Sabha. Select the answer using the code given below:
Answer: (c). The trap: Statement 4 flips the power: the Lok Sabha may accept or reject every Rajya Sabha recommendation. The rest describe Article 109.
UPSC 2023 Q6
With reference to Finance Bill and Money Bill in the Indian Parliament, consider the following statements: 1. When the Lok Sabha transmits Finance Bill to the Rajya Sabha, it can amend or reject the Bill. 2. When the Lok Sabha transmits Money Bill to the Rajya Sabha, it cannot amend or reject the Bill, it can only make recommendations. 3. In the case of disagreement between the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha, there is no joint sitting for Money Bill, but a joint sitting becomes necessary for Finance Bill. How many of the above statements are correct?
Answer: (b). The trap: One word decides statement 3: a joint sitting is possible for a Finance Bill (category II), not "necessary". The first two are right.
UPSC 2018 Q8
Regarding Money Bill, which of the following statements is not correct?
Answer: (c). The trap: Article 110 mentions both funds for custody, but appropriation is only out of the Consolidated Fund. Swapping in the Contingency Fund in (c) makes it the wrong statement. Answer (c).
UPSC 2015 Q7
With reference to the Union Government, consider the following statements: 1. The Department of Revenue is responsible for the preparation of the Union Budget that is presented to the Parliament. 2. No amount can be withdrawn from the Consolidated Fund of India without the authorization from the Parliament of India. 3. All the disbursements made from Public Account also need the authorization from the Parliament of India. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (c). The trap: The Budget is prepared by the Department of Economic Affairs (Budget Division), not Revenue. Public Account payments need no parliamentary vote; only the Consolidated Fund does. Answer (c).
UPSC 2015 Q12
Consider the following statements: 1. The Rajya Sabha has no power either to reject or to amend a Money Bill. 2. The Rajya Sabha cannot vote on the Demands for Grants. 3. The Rajya Sabha cannot discuss the Annual Financial Statement. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (b). The trap: The Rajya Sabha does discuss the Budget; it only cannot vote on demands for grants or reject a Money Bill. Answer (b).
UPSC 2013 Q18
What will follow if a Money Bill is substantially amended by the Rajya Sabha?
Answer: (a). The trap: The Rajya Sabha cannot actually amend a Money Bill; whatever it sends back is only a recommendation. No joint sitting is possible. Answer (a).
UPSC 2012 Q12
Which of the following are the methods of Parliamentary control over public finance in India? 1. Placing Annual Financial Statement before the Parliament. 2. Withdrawal of money from Consolidated Fund of India only after passing the Appropriation Bill. 3. Provisions of supplementary grants and vote-on-account. 4. A periodic or at least a mid-year review of programmes of the Government against macroeconomic forecasts and expenditure by a Parliamentary Budget Office. 5. Introducing the Finance Bill in the Parliament. Select the correct answer using the code given below:
Answer: (a). The trap: Statement 4 describes something India does not have: there is no Parliamentary Budget Office. The other four are real controls. Answer (a).
UPSC 2011 Q1
What is the difference between “vote-on-account” and “interim budget”? 1. The provision of a “vote-on-account” is used by a regular Government, while an “interim budget” is a provision used by a caretaker Government. 2. A “vote-on-account” only deals with the expenditure in the Government’s Budget while an “interim budget” includes both expenditure and receipts. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (b). The trap: A vote-on-account (Art. 116) covers only expenditure for part of the year; an interim budget covers both receipts and expenditure. Statement 1 ties each to one kind of government, which is not a rule. Official answer (b).
UPSC 2011 Q5
When the annual Union Budget is not passed by the Lok Sabha,
Answer: (d). The trap: Defeat of the Budget is a loss of confidence for the whole government, not just the Finance Minister, because of collective responsibility. Answer (d).
UPSC 2011 Q7
All revenues received by the Union Government by way of taxes and other receipts for the conduct of Government business are credited to the
Answer: (c). The trap: Public Account holds money the government only keeps in trust (PF, deposits). All taxes and loans raised go to the Consolidated Fund (Art. 266(1)). Answer (c).
UPSC 2011 Q8
The authorization for the withdrawal of funds from the Consolidated Fund of India must come from
Answer: (b). The trap: The President recommends demands, but only Parliament can authorise withdrawal, through an Appropriation Act (Art. 114, 266(3)). Answer (b).

More practice

UPSC-style questions on the same traps.

1
Within how many days must the Rajya Sabha return a Money Bill?
Answer: (b). Article 109(2): 14 days.
2
Who decides whether a bill is a Money Bill?
Answer: (c). Article 110(3): the Speaker's decision is final.
3
Which of these is NOT charged on the Consolidated Fund of India?
Answer: (d). Ministers' salaries are voted expenditure.
4
Consider: 1. The President can return a Money Bill for reconsideration. 2. A Money Bill needs the President's recommendation to be introduced. 3. The Rajya Sabha can discuss the Budget. How many are correct?
Answer: (b). 2 and 3 are correct; a Money Bill cannot be returned for reconsideration.
5
The Contingency Fund of India is placed at the disposal of:
Answer: (b). Article 267(1): the President.
6
A "token cut" motion reduces a demand by:
Answer: (b). Rs 100, to voice a specific grievance.
7
Statement I: A category I Finance Bill can be rejected by the Rajya Sabha. Statement II: It contains matters other than those listed in Article 110.
Answer: (a). Because it is not purely a Money Bill, the Rajya Sabha has full powers over it.

Confusing pairs: flip cards

Tap to flip

Your score: 0 / 0

1-page table

PointCorrectUPSC's swap
Where a Money Bill startsLok Sabha only, on the President's recommendationEither House
Rajya Sabha on a Money BillRecommend changes within 14 days; cannot reject or amendCan reject; Lok Sabha must accept changes
Who certifies a Money BillSpeaker; decision finalPresident
Joint sittingNever for a Money Bill; possible for a Finance BillNecessary for a Finance Bill
Budget laid byFM on behalf of the President (Art. 112)On behalf of the PM
Demands for grantsOnly on the President's recommendation; voted only in Lok SabhaRajya Sabha votes too
Rajya Sabha and BudgetCan discuss itCannot discuss
Budget prepared byDepartment of Economic AffairsDepartment of Revenue
Consolidated FundAll revenue and loans; withdrawal by lawPublic Account
Public AccountTrust money; no voteNeeds authorisation

Also remember

  • Vote on account (Art. 116): advance grant for part of the year, expenditure only.
  • Interim budget: covers receipts and expenditure; usual in an election year.
  • Charged expenditure (President's salary, judges, CAG, debt charges) is discussed but not voted.
  • Cut motions: policy cut (reduce to Re 1), economy cut, token cut (Rs 100).
  • Budget defeated in the Lok Sabha = loss of confidence; the Council of Ministers resigns.

Notes

+ Read notes (short and detailed)

Most students already have Laxmikant. Open the notes only if you want the full background.

Money Bill

Article 110 defines a Money Bill as one containing only provisions on taxes, government borrowing and guarantees, custody of the Consolidated Fund or Contingency Fund, appropriation from the Consolidated Fund, charged expenditure, and receipts into the funds or the Public Account (UPSC 2018). The Speaker certifies it, and the decision is final.

Under Article 109 it can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha, on the President's recommendation. The Rajya Sabha must return it within 14 days and can only make recommendations, which the Lok Sabha may accept or reject (UPSC 2013, 2015, 2024). There is no joint sitting for a Money Bill. The President cannot send it back for reconsideration.

Finance Bills

Every Money Bill is a Finance Bill, but not every Finance Bill is a Money Bill. A category I Finance Bill (Art. 117(1)) contains Money Bill matters plus other matters: it also starts in the Lok Sabha on the President's recommendation, but the Rajya Sabha can amend or reject it, and a joint sitting can be held if the Houses disagree (UPSC 2023).

A category II Finance Bill (Art. 117(3)) involves spending from the Consolidated Fund; it can start in either House but cannot be passed without the President's recommendation.

The Budget process

The Constitution calls the Budget the Annual Financial Statement (Art. 112). The President causes it to be laid before both Houses; the Finance Minister presents it on the President's behalf (UPSC 2024). It is prepared by the Budget Division of the Department of Economic Affairs (UPSC 2015).

Steps: presentation, general discussion (both Houses), departmental standing committees, voting on demands for grants (Lok Sabha only), the Appropriation Bill and the Finance Bill. No demand can be made except on the President's recommendation (Art. 113(3)).

A vote on account (Art. 116) lets the government spend for part of the year until the Budget passes; an interim budget is a fuller statement of receipts and expenditure, usually presented before a general election (UPSC 2011). If the Lok Sabha defeats the Budget, the whole Council of Ministers resigns (UPSC 2011).

The three funds

All revenues, loans raised and loan repayments received go into the Consolidated Fund of India (Art. 266(1); UPSC 2011); nothing can be withdrawn without Parliament's law (UPSC 2011, 2015). The Public Account (Art. 266(2)) holds money such as provident funds and deposits that the government only keeps in trust; payments from it need no vote. The Contingency Fund (Art. 267) is held by the President for urgent spending, to be made good later by Parliament.

Parliament's controls include the Budget itself, the Appropriation Bill, supplementary grants and vote on account, and the Finance Bill. India has no Parliamentary Budget Office (UPSC 2012).

What could be asked next

  • What happens if the Speaker certifies a bill as a Money Bill: can the courts review it? (Aadhaar case 2018, Rojer Mathew 2019).
  • Charged expenditure: which items are charged on the Consolidated Fund.
  • Cut motions and guillotine.
  • Contingency Fund: size, who holds it, and the Contingency Fund of a State.
  • Supplementary, additional, excess and exceptional grants.
  • Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2003.

In the news

The question of whether the Speaker's Money Bill certificate can be reviewed by courts went to a seven-judge bench, after the Aadhaar and Finance Act 2017 cases. Possible question: who decides whether a bill is a Money Bill, and in which Article?

The Union Budget is presented on 1 February since 2017, and the Railway Budget was merged with it. Possible question: under which Article is the Annual Financial Statement laid?

Sources

  • Constitution of India: Articles 109 to 117, 265 to 267
  • Rules of Procedure and Conduct of Business in Lok Sabha (financial business)
  • Ministry of Finance, Budget Division (Department of Economic Affairs)
  • Supreme Court: K. S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar, 2018), Rojer Mathew (2019)
  • UPSC Prelims GS Paper 1: 2011, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2018, 2023, 2024