Topics › Polity & Governance
Constitutional Bodies
UPSC asked 7 questions on constitutional bodies between 2011 and 2026. Two traps repeat: calling a body constitutional because its name sounds grand, and giving a body powers it does not have, such as the CAG prosecuting or the Attorney General voting.
Constitutional overview: bodies named in the Constitution
Core aim: independent offices that keep elections, recruitment, audit and tax-sharing out of day-to-day political control.
- Art. 76 and 88
- Attorney General: qualified to be a Supreme Court judge, appointed by and serving at the pleasure of the President; can speak in Parliament but not vote.
- Art. 148 to 151
- Comptroller and Auditor General: removed like a Supreme Court judge; audits Union and State accounts; reports go to the President or Governor and then the PAC.
- Art. 280 and 281
- Finance Commission every five years: chairman and four members; recommends sharing of taxes and grants-in-aid.
- Art. 315 to 323
- UPSC and State PSCs.
- Art. 324
- Election Commission.
- Art. 338, 338A, 338B
- National Commissions for SCs, STs (89th Amendment, 2003) and Backward Classes (102nd, 2018).
- Art. 279A
- GST Council (101st Amendment, 2016).
What UPSC asked
1
2
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
Traps
Each trap below is one UPSC actually used. The question where it appeared is linked, so you can solve it right after reading.
Calling a body constitutional because of its grand name. Constitutional: Election Commission, UPSC, Finance Commission, CAG, Attorney General, NCSC, NCST, NCBC (since 2018), GST Council. Not constitutional: NHRC, NCDRC, Law Commission, NITI Aayog, CVC, CBI.
The Attorney General can speak and take part in either House, joint sittings and committees (Art. 88) but cannot vote. Ministers have the same right; the Solicitor General does not, so "the only officers" is wrong.
Giving a body powers it does not have. The CAG audits but has no exchequer control and no power to prosecute; the Finance Commission recommends tax sharing but does not attract foreign capital or fund PSUs, nor plan jobs.
The Attorney General resigns when the government changes, but that is convention; the Constitution says only that he holds office during the President's pleasure (Art. 76(4)).
Word swaps
A swap is the one word UPSC changes to turn a true statement false. Learn the right word and you can spot the swap in seconds.
| The right fact | UPSC swapped it to | Asked in |
|---|---|---|
| NCBC: constitutional (Art. 338B, 2018) | Statutory | 2023 Q5 |
| NHRC: statutory (1993) | Constitutional | 2023 Q5 |
| Law Commission: executive body | Constitutional | 2023 Q5 |
| AG and ministers can take part in Parliament | AG and Solicitor General only | 2022 Q11 |
| AG resigning with the government: convention | Required by the Constitution | 2022 Q11 |
| AG cannot vote in the House | Can vote | 2013 Q14 |
| 14th FC: States' share 42% | Sector-specific grants | 2015 Q14 |
| CAG: no exchequer control, no prosecution | Exchequer control in emergency | 2012 Q10 |
| 13th FC: GST design and local body grants | Jobs plan | 2012 Q13 |
| Finance Commission: Centre-State tax sharing | Foreign capital, PSU finance | 2011 Q3 |
| 15th FC: 41% to States (N. K. Singh) | 42% | Likely next |
| 16th FC chair: Arvind Panagariya | N. K. Singh | Likely next |
Solve the past questions
Try each question first. Tap an option to see the answer and the trap.
More practice
UPSC-style questions on the same traps.
Confusing pairs: flip cards
Tap to flip
1-page table
| Body | Article | Key fact | UPSC's swap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Attorney General | 76, 88 | Speaks, joins committees, no vote | Can vote; SG has same right |
| Advocate General (State) | 165, 177 | State counterpart of the AG | Appointed by the President |
| CAG | 148 to 151 | Audit only; reports to President | Exchequer control, prosecution |
| Finance Commission | 280 | Tax sharing and grants | Foreign capital, PSU finance |
| NCSC / NCST | 338 / 338A | Split by 89th Amendment, 2003 | One commission |
| NCBC | 338B | Constitutional since 2018 | Statutory |
| GST Council | 279A | Union FM chairs | Statutory |
| NHRC, NCDRC, Law Commission | None | Statutory or executive | Constitutional |
Also remember
- 14th Finance Commission (Y. V. Reddy, 2015 to 2020): States' share 32% to 42%.
- 15th (N. K. Singh, 2021 to 2026): 41% after Jammu and Kashmir became a UT.
- 16th (Arvind Panagariya): constituted December 2023, report for 2026 to 2031.
- CAG holds office for six years or until 65; not eligible for further government office.
- Attorney General: no fixed term; not a full-time officer; can take private practice except against the government.
Notes
+ Read notes (short and detailed)
Most students already have Laxmikant. Open the notes only if you want the full background.
Which bodies are constitutional
A body is constitutional only if an Article creates it. Among national commissions, the NCSC (338), NCST (338A) and NCBC (338B, added by the 102nd Amendment in 2018) are constitutional; the NHRC (Act of 1993), the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (Consumer Protection Act) and the Law Commission (executive) are not (UPSC 2023).
Attorney General
The Attorney General is the Government of India's top law officer, appointed by the President from those qualified to be Supreme Court judges, and holds office during the President's pleasure (Art. 76). The convention of resigning when the government changes is not in the Constitution (UPSC 2022).
Under Article 88 he can speak and take part in the proceedings of either House, joint sittings and any committee he is named to, but cannot vote (UPSC 2013). Ministers have the same right; the Solicitor General does not (UPSC 2022).
CAG
The CAG audits the accounts of the Union, the States and bodies funded by them, including government companies, and submits reports to the President (Union) or Governor (State); they are examined by the Public Accounts Committee (UPSC 2012). The reports can be used by investigating agencies.
Unlike the British Comptroller, the Indian CAG has no control over the issue of money from the Consolidated Fund, and has no judicial or prosecuting powers (UPSC 2012). He is removed only like a Supreme Court judge.
Finance Commission
The President constitutes a Finance Commission every five years (Art. 280). It recommends how the net proceeds of taxes are shared between the Centre and States, the principles for grants-in-aid, and measures to augment State funds for Panchayats and Municipalities. It does not attract foreign capital or allocate money among PSUs (UPSC 2011).
The 13th Commission (Vijay Kelkar) proposed a GST design with a compensation package and grants to local bodies as a share of the divisible pool (UPSC 2012). The 14th (Y. V. Reddy) raised the States' share from 32 to 42 per cent and moved away from sector-specific grants (UPSC 2015). The 15th (N. K. Singh) set it at 41 per cent.
What could be asked next
- Qualifications, term and removal of the CAG, and his relationship with the PAC.
- Composition and powers of the GST Council, and the weight of the Centre's vote (one-third).
- Advocate General of a State (Art. 165) and his right to speak in the State Legislature (Art. 177).
- Terms of reference of the 16th Finance Commission.
- NCSC vs NCST: which amendment split them.
- Solicitor General: a statutory post under the Law Officers (Conditions of Service) Rules.
In the news
The 16th Finance Commission under Arvind Panagariya submitted its report for 2026 to 2031. Possible question: under which Article is the Finance Commission constituted, and who is its chairman?
CAG audit reports on State finances and off-budget borrowing. Possible question: to whom does the CAG submit reports on State accounts?
Sources
- Constitution of India: Articles 76, 88, 148 to 151, 165, 177, 279A, 280, 281, 315 to 324, 338 to 338B
- Constitution (89th, 101st and 102nd Amendment) Acts
- Reports of the 13th, 14th and 15th Finance Commissions
- Comptroller and Auditor-General's (Duties, Powers and Conditions of Service) Act, 1971
- UPSC Prelims GS Paper 1: 2011, 2012, 2013, 2015, 2022, 2023