Topics › Polity & Governance
Constitutional Amendment and Basic Structure
UPSC asked 7 questions on amending the Constitution between 2011 and 2026. The traps are extra conditions that do not exist ("Lok Sabha only", "all States", "President's prior recommendation") and famous changes credited to the wrong amendment.
Constitutional overview: Part XX (Article 368)
Core aim: let the Constitution change through Parliament, with State consent for federal matters and the courts guarding the basic structure.
- Art. 368(1)
- Parliament may amend by way of addition, variation or repeal.
- Art. 368(2)
- Bill can start in either House (not a State Legislature); special majority in each House (majority of total membership and two-thirds present and voting); no joint sitting; President must assent.
- Proviso to 368(2)
- Ratification by half the State Legislatures for: President's election, extent of Union and State executive power, Supreme Court and High Courts, distribution of legislative powers and the Lists, States' representation in Parliament, GST Council, Art. 368 itself.
- Simple majority
- Many provisions are changed by ordinary law and are not "amendments" under Art. 368: new States (Art. 4), second chambers (Art. 169), Fifth and Sixth Schedules.
- Basic structure
- Judicial limit on amendment since Kesavananda Bharati (1973).
What UPSC asked
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
Traps
Each trap below is one UPSC actually used. The question where it appeared is linked, so you can solve it right after reading.
Pinning a famous change on the wrong amendment. 24th (1971): Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights, assent compulsory. 39th (1975): PM's election beyond courts. 42nd (1976): mini-Constitution. 44th (1978): undid Emergency excesses. 99th (2014): NJAC, struck down 2015.
Adding a requirement that does not exist: "Lok Sabha only", "all States must ratify", "prior recommendation of the President". The real rules: either House, half the States for federal provisions, no recommendation needed.
Assuming anything about States needs ratification. The proviso to Art. 368(2) lists: election of the President, extent of Union and State executive power, Supreme Court and High Courts, distribution of legislative powers and the Lists, representation of States in Parliament, GST Council, and Art. 368 itself. The Governor's office is not on it.
Basic structure is judge-made and nowhere defined in the Constitution. Article 368 does use "addition, variation or repeal", even though "repeal" sounds too strong.
Word swaps
A swap is the one word UPSC changes to turn a true statement false. Learn the right word and you can spot the swap in seconds.
| The right fact | UPSC swapped it to | Asked in |
|---|---|---|
| Art. 368: addition, variation or repeal | Repeal not allowed | 2024 Q6 |
| Governor's office: no State ratification | Needs half the States | 2025 Q2 |
| Union List changes: half the States ratify | Parliament alone | 2025 Q2 |
| No prior recommendation of the President | Prior recommendation needed | 2022 Q7 |
| President must assent (24th Amendment) | Can withhold | 2022 Q7 |
| Basic structure: not defined in the Constitution | Defined in the Constitution | 2020 Q3 |
| PM's election shielded: 39th Amendment | 44th Amendment | 2019 Q13 |
| 99th Amendment (NJAC): struck down 2015 | Upheld | 2019 Q13 |
| Amendment bill: either House | Lok Sabha only | 2013 Q15 |
| Federal provisions: half the States | All States | 2013 Q15 |
| Amendment bill cannot start in a State Legislature | States can initiate | Likely next |
Solve the past questions
Try each question first. Tap an option to see the answer and the trap.
More practice
UPSC-style questions on the same traps.
Confusing pairs: flip cards
Tap to flip
1-page table
| Point | Rule | UPSC's swap |
|---|---|---|
| Where it starts | Either House | Lok Sabha only |
| President's recommendation | Not needed | Needed |
| Majority | Special in each House | Joint sitting allowed |
| State ratification | Half the States, only for listed federal matters | All States |
| Governor's office | Not on the federal list | Needs ratification |
| Assent | Compulsory (24th Amendment) | Can be withheld |
| Basic structure | Judge-made; not defined | Defined in the Constitution |
| PM's election beyond courts | 39th Amendment (struck down in Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain) | 44th Amendment |
Also remember
- Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1965): Parliament can amend FRs. Golaknath (1967): cannot.
- 24th Amendment (1971) restored the power; Kesavananda (1973): yes, but not the basic structure.
- Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain (1975): free and fair elections part of basic structure.
- Minerva Mills (1980): limited amending power is itself basic structure.
- NJAC (99th) struck down in 2015 for independence of the judiciary.
Notes
+ Read notes (short and detailed)
Most students already have Laxmikant. Open the notes only if you want the full background.
Procedure
Under Article 368, Parliament may amend any provision by way of addition, variation or repeal (UPSC 2024). A bill can be introduced in either House, by a minister or a private member, without the President's prior recommendation (UPSC 2013, 2022).
Each House must pass it by a special majority: a majority of its total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting. There is no joint sitting, and the President must give assent (24th Amendment, 1971; UPSC 2022).
Amendments that affect federal provisions also need ratification by the Legislatures of at least half the States (UPSC 2013). These include the Lists in the Seventh Schedule and the extent of executive power of the Union and the States, but not the conditions of the Governor's office (UPSC 2025).
Basic structure
In Golaknath (1967) the Court said Parliament could not amend Fundamental Rights. The 24th Amendment responded, and in Kesavananda Bharati (1973) the Court allowed amendment of any part but not of the "basic structure". The Constitution itself does not define the term (UPSC 2020).
Elements identified by the courts include the supremacy of the Constitution, rule of law, judicial review, federalism, secularism, free and fair elections, separation of powers and independence of the judiciary. The 99th Amendment (NJAC) was struck down in 2015 for violating judicial independence (UPSC 2019).
The 39th Amendment (1975) put the election of the PM and the Speaker beyond the courts; the Court struck down that clause in Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain (1975). The 44th Amendment (1978) later reversed many Emergency-era changes (UPSC 2019).
What could be asked next
- Three ways of amending: simple majority, special majority, special majority plus State ratification.
- Which provisions need State ratification under the proviso to Article 368(2).
- Landmark amendments: 1st, 7th, 24th, 42nd, 44th, 52nd, 61st, 73rd, 74th, 86th, 101st, 103rd, 106th.
- Elements of basic structure named in Kesavananda, Indira Gandhi and Minerva Mills.
- Can a private member introduce a constitution amendment bill?
- Ninth Schedule review after I. R. Coelho (2007).
In the news
The Constitution (129th Amendment) Bill, 2024 on simultaneous elections; debate on whether it needs State ratification. Possible question: which matters in Article 368(2) need ratification by half the States?
The 2024 judgment upholding "Socialist" and "Secular" in the Preamble. Possible question: was the Preamble amended under Article 368?
Sources
- Constitution of India: Article 368, Articles 4, 169, Fifth and Sixth Schedules
- Constitution (24th, 39th, 42nd, 44th and 99th Amendment) Acts
- Supreme Court: Golaknath (1967), Kesavananda Bharati (1973), Indira Gandhi v Raj Narain (1975), Minerva Mills (1980), Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association (2015)
- UPSC Prelims GS Paper 1: 2013, 2019, 2020, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025