हिंदी में पढ़ें, यहाँ क्लिक करें →
हिंदी

Topics › Polity & Governance

Centre-State Relations

UPSC asked 8 questions on Centre-State relations between 2011 and 2026. The trick is usually a power quietly moved to the wrong side: the Centre making minor-mineral rules, the Lok Sabha passing an Article 249 resolution, States needing to consent to treaty laws.

8past questions
8of the last 16 years (2011 to 2026)
3trap types
10word swaps
Constitutional overview: Part XI (Articles 245 to 263) and Part XII

Core aim: divide legislative, executive and financial power between the Union and the States, with a strong Centre.

Art. 245 and 246
Territorial extent of laws; Union, State and Concurrent Lists (Seventh Schedule).
Art. 248
Residuary powers with Parliament.
Art. 249 to 253
Parliament on State List: national interest by Rajya Sabha resolution (249), emergency (250), consent of two or more States (252), treaties (253).
Art. 254
Repugnancy: Union law prevails in the Concurrent List unless a State law reserved and assented by the President.
Art. 256 and 257
States must comply with Union laws; Union can give directions.
Art. 263
Inter-State Council.
Art. 268 to 293
Distribution of revenues; Finance Commission (280).

What UPSC asked

2011
0
2012
0
2013
1
2014
1
2015
0
2016
1
2017
1
2018
0
2019
1
2020
0
2021
1
2022
0
2023
0
2024
1
2025
1
2026
0

Traps

Each trap below is one UPSC actually used. The question where it appeared is linked, so you can solve it right after reading.

Reversed power

Giving the Centre a power that belongs to the States. Rules for minor mineral concessions and against illegal mining are made by the States (MMDR Act, Sections 15 and 23C); the Centre only notifies which minerals are minor. UPSC asked this in 2019 and 2025.

Which House, which majority

Article 249 (State List in the national interest) needs a Rajya Sabha resolution by two-thirds of members present and voting, not the Lok Sabha. Article 253 (treaties) needs no consent at all. Article 252 needs two or more State Legislatures to ask.

US federalism vs Indian

Treating India like the USA. Indian federation did not come from an agreement among States, States cannot secede, and representation in the Rajya Sabha is by population. The essential federal features are a division of powers, a written Constitution and an independent judiciary.

Word swaps

A swap is the one word UPSC changes to turn a true statement false. Learn the right word and you can spot the swap in seconds.

The right factUPSC swapped it toAsked in
Minor mineral rules: made by States (MMDR s.15)By the Centre2025 Q12
Centre notifies minor mineralsStates notify2025 Q12
Sand: a minor mineralMajor mineral2019 Q5
Essential federal feature: independent judiciaryRegional parties in Cabinet2021 Q16
Indian federation: not by agreement of StatesResult of an agreement2017 Q1
Art. 249: Rajya Sabha, 2/3 present and votingLok Sabha2016 Q2
Pre-GST sales tax: levied and collected by the StateBy the Centre2014 Q11
Art. 253 treaties: no State's consent neededConsent of States concerned2013 Q12
Residuary powers: Parliament (Art. 248)StatesLikely next
Art. 252: two or more States requestOne StateLikely next

Solve the past questions

Try each question first. Tap an option to see the answer and the trap.

UPSC 2025 Q12
Consider the following statements: Statement I: In India, State Governments have no power for making rules for grant of concessions in respect of extraction of minor minerals even though such minerals are located in their territories. Statement II: In India, the Central Government has the power to notify minor minerals under the relevant law. Which one of the following is correct in respect of the above statements?
Answer: (d). The trap: Statement I is the exact reverse of the law: Section 15 of the MMDR Act, 1957 lets States make rules for minor mineral concessions. The Centre does notify what counts as a minor mineral (Section 3(e)). Asked in 2019 too.
UPSC 2021 Q16
Which one of the following in Indian polity is an essential feature that indicates that it is federal in character?
Answer: (a). The trap: Options (b) and (c) describe representation, which unitary States can also have. An independent judiciary to settle Centre-State disputes is an essential federal feature.
UPSC 2019 Q5
With reference to the management of minor minerals in India, consider the following statements: 1. Sand is a 'minor mineral' according to the prevailing law in the country. 2. State Governments have the power to grant mining leases of minor minerals, but the powers regarding the formation of rules related to the grant of minor minerals lie with the Central Government. 3. State Governments have the power to frame rules to prevent illegal mining of minor minerals. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
Answer: (a). The trap: Statement 2 gives the rule-making power to the Centre; it lies with the States. Sand is a minor mineral, and States can frame rules against illegal mining (Section 23C).
UPSC 2017 Q1
Which one of the following is not a feature of Indian federalism?
Answer: (d). The trap: Unequal Rajya Sabha representation sounds un-federal but is how India works. Indian federation was not formed by an agreement among States (unlike the USA); it is an "indestructible Union of destructible States". Answer (d).
UPSC 2016 Q2
The Parliament of India acquires the power to legislate on any item in the State List in the national interest if a resolution to that effect is passed by the
Answer: (d). The trap: The Rajya Sabha represents the States, so Article 249 gives the power to it, by two-thirds of members present and voting. Options with the Lok Sabha are the trap. Answer (d).
UPSC 2014 Q11
The sales tax you pay while purchasing a toothpaste is a
Answer: (d). The trap: Before GST (2017), sales tax on goods sold within a State was a State List tax (Entry 54), levied and collected by the State. Answer (d). Today this would be GST.
UPSC 2013 Q12
The Parliament can make any law for whole or any part of India for implementing international treaties
Answer: (d). The trap: Consent options look fair but Article 253 needs none: Parliament can legislate on any subject, including State List subjects, to implement treaties. Answer (d).
UPSC 2024
Which one of the following statements is correct as per the Constitution of India?
Answer: (c). The trap: Inter-State quarantine is Entry 81 of the Union List. Inter-State trade and migration are Union subjects, and corporation tax is levied by the Union. Answer (c).

More practice

UPSC-style questions on the same traps.

1
Residuary powers of legislation in India lie with:
Answer: (b). Article 248.
2
A resolution under Article 249 remains in force for up to:
Answer: (b). One year, renewable.
3
Which commission was set up by Tamil Nadu to study Centre-State relations?
Answer: (c). Rajamannar Committee (1969).
4
Consider: 1. Parliament can legislate on a State subject during a national emergency. 2. Two States can request Parliament to legislate on a State subject. 3. Parliament needs States' consent to implement a treaty. How many are correct?
Answer: (b). 1 and 2 (Art. 250, 252). Art. 253 needs no consent.
5
In which case did the Supreme Court hold federalism to be part of the basic structure?
Answer: (c). S. R. Bommai (1994).
6
Statement I: The Rajya Sabha alone can pass a resolution under Article 249. Statement II: The Rajya Sabha represents the States.
Answer: (a). Its role as the States' House is why it gets this power.

Confusing pairs: flip cards

Tap to flip

Your score: 0 / 0

1-page table

ProvisionRuleUPSC's swap
Art. 249Rajya Sabha resolution, 2/3 present and voting; one year at a timeLok Sabha
Art. 250During national emergency, Parliament on State ListNeeds States' consent
Art. 252Two or more States pass resolutions; others may adoptOne State
Art. 253Treaties: no consent neededConsent of States concerned
Art. 248Residuary: ParliamentStates
Minor mineralsStates make rules (MMDR s.15); Centre notifies (s.3(e))Centre makes rules
Federal featureIndependent judiciary, division of powersAgreement of States
Rajya Sabha seatsBy population (unequal)Equal, as in the US

Also remember

  • Commissions on Centre-State relations: Rajamannar (Tamil Nadu, 1969), Sarkaria (1983), Punchhi (2007).
  • India: "indestructible Union of destructible States"; Parliament can change State boundaries (Art. 3).
  • GST (101st Amendment, 2016) replaced most State sales taxes; Art. 246A gives both concurrent power.
  • S. R. Bommai (1994): federalism is part of the basic structure.
  • All-India Services (Art. 312) are a unitary feature.

Notes

+ Read notes (short and detailed)

Most students already have Laxmikant. Open the notes only if you want the full background.

Is India federal?

India has the federal features of a written Constitution, a division of powers between the Union and States, a rigid amendment process for federal provisions and an independent judiciary to settle disputes; the independent judiciary is the essential one in UPSC's answer (2021).

It also has unitary features: a strong Centre, single citizenship, a single Constitution, All India Services, emergency powers and Parliament's power to change State boundaries. It was not formed by an agreement among States (UPSC 2017); States are represented in the Rajya Sabha by population, so unequally.

Legislative relations

The Seventh Schedule divides subjects into the Union, State and Concurrent Lists; residuary powers lie with Parliament (Art. 248). Parliament can legislate on State List subjects in five cases: a Rajya Sabha resolution in the national interest by two-thirds present and voting (Art. 249; UPSC 2016), a national emergency (Art. 250), a request by two or more States (Art. 252), implementing treaties without any State's consent (Art. 253; UPSC 2013), and President's rule (Art. 356).

Minor minerals and taxes

Regulation of mines is split: the Centre regulates under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, and can notify minerals as minor (Section 3(e)); States make rules for minor mineral concessions (Section 15) and to prevent illegal mining (Section 23C). Sand is a minor mineral (UPSC 2019, 2025).

Before GST, sales tax on intra-State sales was levied and collected by States (UPSC 2014). Since 2017 GST is levied concurrently by both (Art. 246A), with the GST Council (Art. 279A) making recommendations.

What could be asked next

  • Article 254: repugnancy between Union and State laws in the Concurrent List.
  • Sarkaria and Punchhi Commission recommendations on Governors and Article 356.
  • Article 356 safeguards after S. R. Bommai (1994).
  • Taxes levied by the Union but collected and kept by States (Art. 268).
  • Article 3: Parliament's power to form new States and change boundaries.
  • Inter-State water disputes (Art. 262).

In the news

The 2024 nine-judge ruling in Mineral Area Development Authority held that States can tax mineral rights and royalty is not a tax. Possible question: which list gives States the power to tax mineral rights?

Disputes over Governors withholding assent and the Supreme Court's 2025 Tamil Nadu ruling. Possible question: which commission recommended that Governors not be active politicians?

Sources

  • Constitution of India: Articles 3, 245 to 263, 268 to 293, Seventh Schedule
  • Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (Sections 3(e), 15, 23C)
  • Sarkaria Commission (1988) and Punchhi Commission (2010) reports
  • Supreme Court: S. R. Bommai (1994), Mineral Area Development Authority (2024)
  • UPSC Prelims GS Paper 1: 2013, 2014, 2016, 2017, 2019, 2021, 2024, 2025