Topics › Polity & Governance
Anti-defection Law
UPSC asked 3 questions on the anti-defection law between 2011 and 2026. The traps either reverse the six-month rule for nominated members or mix up who decides a defection case with who decides other disqualifications.
Constitutional overview: Tenth Schedule and Articles 102(2), 191(2)
Core aim: stop elected members from switching parties for gain, while allowing genuine mergers.
- Para 2
- Disqualification for voluntarily giving up party membership or voting against the whip without permission (unless condoned within 15 days); independents who join a party; nominated members who join after six months.
- Para 4
- Merger exception: when at least two-thirds of the legislature party agree to merge.
- Para 6
- The Speaker or Chairman decides; Kihoto Hollohan (1992) made the decision subject to judicial review.
- 91st Amendment (2003)
- Deleted the one-third "split" exception; defectors cannot hold ministerial or remunerative political posts until re-elected.
What UPSC asked
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
0
Traps
Each trap below is one UPSC actually used. The question where it appeared is linked, so you can solve it right after reading.
Mixing Tenth Schedule disqualification (decided by the Speaker or Chairman) with other disqualifications under Article 102 (decided by the President on the Election Commission's opinion, Art. 103).
A nominated member who joins a party within six months is safe; after six months he is disqualified. UPSC writes it the other way.
Word swaps
A swap is the one word UPSC changes to turn a true statement false. Learn the right word and you can spot the swap in seconds.
| The right fact | UPSC swapped it to | Asked in |
|---|---|---|
| Tenth Schedule disqualification: Speaker decides | President on ministers' advice | 2025 Q10 |
| "Political party" is in the Tenth Schedule | Not mentioned anywhere | 2025 Q10 |
| Nominated member: may join a party within 6 months | Cannot join within 6 months | 2022 Q8 |
| No time limit for the Speaker | Three months | 2022 Q8 |
| Tenth Schedule: 52nd Amendment, 1985 | 42nd Amendment | 2014 Q10 |
| Merger: two-thirds of the legislature party | One-third split | Likely next |
| Split exception: deleted in 2003 (91st) | Still allowed | Likely next |
Solve the past questions
Try each question first. Tap an option to see the answer and the trap.
More practice
UPSC-style questions on the same traps.
Confusing pairs: flip cards
Tap to flip
1-page table
| Point | Rule | UPSC's swap |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Speaker or Chairman | President |
| Other disqualifications (Art. 102) | President, on ECI opinion | On ministers' advice |
| Nominated member | Can join a party within 6 months | Cannot join within 6 months |
| Independent member | Disqualified if he joins any party | Free to join |
| Time limit to decide | None in the law | Three months |
| Merger | Two-thirds of legislature party | One-third |
| Schedule | Tenth (52nd Amendment, 1985) | Ninth or Eighth |
Also remember
- Kihoto Hollohan (1992): Speaker acts as a tribunal; decision open to judicial review.
- Keisham Meghachandra (2020): Speakers should decide within three months (a direction, not a statute).
- Subhash Desai (2023): the party whip is appointed by the political party, not the legislature party.
- Article 75(1B) and 164(1B): defectors cannot be ministers until re-elected.
Notes
+ Read notes (short and detailed)
Most students already have Laxmikant. Open the notes only if you want the full background.
What the law says
The 52nd Amendment (1985) added the Tenth Schedule (UPSC 2014). A member is disqualified for voluntarily giving up membership of his party or voting against its direction without permission. An independent is disqualified if he joins a party after election. A nominated member may join a party within six months of taking his seat; joining after that disqualifies him (UPSC 2022).
A merger is protected only if at least two-thirds of the legislature party agree. The 91st Amendment (2003) removed the earlier one-third split exception.
Who decides
Questions of disqualification under the Tenth Schedule are decided by the Speaker or Chairman; the law sets no time limit (UPSC 2022), though the Supreme Court in 2020 asked for a decision within three months. Other disqualifications under Article 102 are decided by the President on the Election Commission's opinion (Art. 103), so a statement giving Tenth Schedule cases to the President on the ministers' advice is wrong (UPSC 2025).
The words "political party" do appear in the Constitution, in the Tenth Schedule (UPSC 2025).
What could be asked next
- Whip and its legal status.
- Disqualification of a member who is absent from voting.
- Judicial review of the Speaker's decision (Kihoto Hollohan).
- Splits vs mergers after 2003.
- Calls for an independent tribunal instead of the Speaker.
In the news
Delays by Speakers in deciding defection petitions in several States (2023 to 2025). Possible question: does the Tenth Schedule set a time limit for the Speaker?
The 2023 Maharashtra ruling on which faction is the real party. Possible question: who appoints the party whip?
Sources
- Constitution of India: Tenth Schedule; Articles 75(1B), 102, 103, 164(1B), 191
- Constitution (52nd and 91st Amendment) Acts
- Supreme Court: Kihoto Hollohan (1992), Keisham Meghachandra (2020), Subhash Desai (2023)
- UPSC Prelims GS Paper 1: 2014, 2022, 2025