हिंदी में पढ़ें, यहाँ क्लिक करें →
हिंदी

All current affairs › Polity & Governance · 16 November 2026

Supreme Court mulls asking judicial academies to scan High Court rulings for remarks against women

A bench led by the CJI heard the suo motu case that began with a Patna High Court verdict.

On 16 November 2026 a bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana suggested that State Judicial Academies review the judgments of their High Courts to find objectionable observations about women. After such a survey the Court could direct High Courts to act on their own and remove those remarks from their judgments. The bench gave the accused, Himanshu Pathak, one week to reply and deferred the hearing.

The case began with a Patna High Court order of 9 July that set aside Pathak's conviction for attempt to rape in a 2008 case. The prosecution had alleged that he locked a woman in his studio, tried to remove her salwar and pressed her chest. The High Court held this amounted to outraging modesty, not attempt to rape. The Supreme Court took suo motu notice and issued notice to the accused in September.

Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta, who is assisting the Court, pointed to other judgments with offending remarks. The Court has also issued notice in a connected matter.

Facts to remember (SSC)

  • On 16 November 2026 the Supreme Court suggested State Judicial Academies scan High Court judgments for objectionable remarks about women.
  • The bench was CJI Surya Kant with Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana.
  • The case is a suo motu matter arising from a Patna High Court order of 9 July 2026.
  • The accused was given one week to reply and the hearing was deferred.

UPSC angle

Suo motu cognisance lets the Supreme Court start a case on its own under its powers to do complete justice and protect fundamental rights. Here the Court is looking at a systemic issue, the language used in judgments, and not only the one verdict. State Judicial Academies are training bodies for judges of each State, and using them for review is an administrative route that does not need the Court to set aside decisions. Courts have held that a person's dignity is part of Article 21. Mains angle: gender sensitisation in the judiciary, judicial accountability without hurting independence, and the use of amicus assistance in suo motu cases.

Timeline

2026: On 9 July the Patna High Court set aside a conviction for attempt to rape. The Supreme Court took suo motu cognisance and issued notice to the accused in September. On 16 November the bench moved towards asking State Judicial Academies to survey High Court judgments.

Try the MCQs

1
Which bodies did the Supreme Court bench suggest should review High Court judgments for objectionable remarks about women?
Answer: (b). On 16 November 2026 the bench leaned towards directing State Judicial Academies to survey the judgments of their High Courts.
2
Consider the following statements about the Supreme Court hearing of 16 November 2026: 1. The matter is being heard on the Court's own motion. 2. The Court suggested a survey of High Court judgments by State Judicial Academies. 3. The Court set aside the Patna High Court order on that day. Which of the statements is/are correct?
Answer: (c). The case is suo motu and the survey was suggested, so 1 and 2 are right. The Court gave the accused a week to reply and deferred the hearing, so it did not set aside the order that day.
Your score: 0 / 0

Linked topic page

Supreme Court, High Courts and Writs: traps, swaps and past questions →

Sources

How we checked this

Hearing date 16 Nov 2026, bench, suggestion to State Judicial Academies, one week to the accused, Patna High Court order of 9 July 2026, notice to the accused in September and the allegations matched across Bar and Bench, LiveLaw and ETV Bharat. The exact day of notice (23 September, Bar and Bench only), the month the suo motu case began and a compilation by Shobha Gupta were not confirmed by a second outlet and were removed or generalised. This was a hearing, not a final order. The Supreme Court order itself could not be reached.